Best Drum Smoker

February 12, 2025

If you love barbecue and want to elevate your smoking game, a drum smoker is one of the best investments you can make. Known for their efficiency, ease of use, and ability to maintain steady temperatures, drum smokers are the go-to choice for both beginners and pitmasters.

In this guide, we’ll explore the best drum smokers on the market, compare their features, and provide insights to help you choose the perfect one for your BBQ needs.

What Is a Drum Smoker?

A drum smoker, often called an Ugly Drum Smoker (UDS), is a vertical smoker made from a steel drum. It operates by using a charcoal basket at the bottom, allowing heat and smoke to rise and cook food evenly. These smokers are known for their ability to hold consistent temperatures for long periods, making them ideal for low-and-slow cooking.

Why Choose a Drum Smoker?

Drum smokers offer several advantages over traditional smokers:

Superior Heat Retention: Their vertical design and thick steel body help maintain steady temperatures.
Fuel Efficiency: Uses minimal charcoal while delivering long cooking times.

Versatility: Can be used for smoking, grilling, and even searing.
Ease of Use: Many models require little maintenance and are beginner-friendly.
Great Flavor: The natural airflow system enhances smoke penetration, giving meat a rich, smoky flavor.

Best Drum Smokers of 2024

We’ve selected the top drum smokers based on performance, durability, ease of use, and customer reviews.

1. Pit Barrel Cooker – Best Overall

Why We Love It: The Pit Barrel Cooker is one of the most popular drum smokers due to its simple yet effective design. It’s pre-assembled, making it ideal for beginners.

Key Features:

Heavy-duty 18.5” steel drum

Hanging hooks for meat (ensuring even smoking)
No-hassle air vent system
Durable porcelain enamel finish

Easy-to-use charcoal basket

✔ Pros:

Set-it-and-forget-it design

Versatile cooking options (grilling and smoking)
Holds temperature well

❌ Cons:

No built-in thermometer
Limited airflow control

Best For: Beginners and backyard BBQ enthusiasts looking for a reliable and user-friendly drum smoker.

2. Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco – Best for Precise Control

Why We Love It: The Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco stands out due to its adjustable airflow system, allowing better control over temperature.

Key Features:

22-gauge steel construction
Adjustable intake and exhaust dampers

Removable charcoal basket for easy cleanup
Adjustable cooking grates
Side shelf for extra space

✔ Pros:

Excellent temperature control
Heavy-duty, durable construction

Easy to clean

❌ Cons:

Smaller cooking capacity than other drum smokers

Slightly higher price point

Best For: Those who want precise control over their smoking process.

3. Gateway Drum Smoker – Best for Competition BBQ

Why We Love It: This smoker is a favorite among BBQ competitors because of its fast-cooking capability and high-quality construction.

Key Features:

55-gallon steel drum design
Multi-level cooking grates
Wide temperature range (250-400°F)

Easy lift lid for quick access
Heavy-duty caster wheels for mobility

✔ Pros:

Faster cook times compared to traditional smokers
High-quality materials built to last
Holds a large amount of meat

❌ Cons:

Expensive
Learning curve for beginners

Best For: Serious BBQ competitors or anyone looking for premium quality.

4. Weber Smokey Mountain – Best for Versatility

Why We Love It: While not a traditional drum smoker, the Weber Smokey Mountain has a vertical design similar to drum smokers, providing exceptional smoke control.

Key Features:

Available in three sizes (14″, 18″, 22″)

Porcelain-enameled steel body
Built-in thermometer
Water pan for moisture retention

Dual air dampers for precise heat control

✔ Pros:

Versatile smoking capabilities

Excellent temperature stability
Well-known brand with great customer support

❌ Cons:

Smaller cooking capacity
Requires frequent refueling

Best For: BBQ enthusiasts who want a reliable, all-in-one smoker.

5. Barrel House Cooker – Best Budget Option

Why We Love It: The Barrel House Cooker is an affordable alternative to high-end drum smokers while still offering great performance.

Key Features:

Hanging hooks for optimal meat placement
Compact and portable design

Enamel-coated steel construction
Easily adjustable air vents

✔ Pros:

Budget-friendly
Lightweight and portable
Easy setup

❌ Cons:

Smaller capacity
Not as durable as high-end models

Best For: Budget-conscious BBQ lovers looking for a solid entry-level smoker.

How to Choose the Best Drum Smoker

When selecting a drum smoker, consider the following factors:

1. Size & Capacity

Smaller models (14”-18”): Ideal for small families.

Larger models (22”-55”): Best for big gatherings and competition BBQ.

2. Build Quality

Look for heavy-duty steel construction with ceramic or enamel coating for durability.

3. Temperature Control

Adjustable air vents and dampers help with precise heat management.

Thicker drum walls provide better heat retention.

4. Ease of Use & Maintenance

Models with removable ash pans and simple airflow systems are easier to clean.

5. Cooking Options

Some drum smokers offer grates, hooks, or searing options, allowing multi-purpose cooking.

Tips for Using a Drum Smoker

To get the best results, follow these tips:

1. Use the Right Charcoal

Lump charcoal burns hotter and cleaner.
Briquettes provide longer, more consistent heat.

2. Control Airflow

Adjust the intake and exhaust dampers to maintain desired temperatures.

3. Hang Your Meat

Hanging meat increases smoke circulation, leading to even cooking.

4. Use a Water Pan

Helps maintain moisture and prevent meat from drying out.

5. Monitor with a Thermometer

Since some drum smokers don’t come with built-in thermometers, use a digital probe thermometer to monitor internal temperatures.

Final Verdict: Which Drum Smoker is Best?

Best Overall: Pit Barrel Cooker (Perfect balance of performance and price)
Best for Precision: Oklahoma Joe’s Bronco (Superior temperature control)

Best for Competition BBQ: Gateway Drum Smoker (Fast cooking, premium build)
Best for Versatility: Weber Smokey Mountain (Reliable and multi-purpose)
Best Budget Option: Barrel House Cooker (Affordable and portable)

If you’re serious about low-and-slow cooking, a drum smoker is an excellent investment. Whether you’re a beginner or a seasoned pitmaster, there’s a model on this list that will help you achieve mouthwatering BBQ perfection.