When summer heat hits or you just need a refreshing treat, nothing beats the simple joy of a popsicle. These icy delights have been a staple of childhood nostalgia and adult indulgence alike, but not all popsicles are created equal.
With an ever-growing market of options—from artificially flavored sugar bombs to fruit-forward, health-conscious bars—choosing the best store-bought popsicle can feel overwhelming. That’s why we’ve ranked the top 10 store-bought popsicle brands based on two key factors: flavor and ingredients. Flavor is king—does it taste vibrant, balanced, and satisfying? Ingredients matter too— are they real, natural, and free of unnecessary additives? Let’s dive into the frosty world of popsicles and uncover the best the freezer aisle has to offer.
10. Popsicle (The Classic Lineup)
Kicking off our list is the brand that practically invented the category: Popsicle. Since 1905, when 11-year-old Frank Epperson accidentally froze a soda with a stick in it, Popsicle has been synonymous with frozen treats. The classic lineup—think Cherry, Orange, and Grape—lands at number 10 due to its nostalgic charm, but it’s held back by a reliance on artificial flavors and colors.
Flavor-wise, these popsicles deliver a punchy, sweet taste that’s instantly recognizable. The Cherry is bold and candy-like, the Orange has a bright citrus zing, and the Grape offers a deep, juicy note. However, they often taste more like flavored ice than real fruit, and the texture can be a bit too icy, leaving a squeaky bite that some find off-putting. Ingredient-wise, you’ll find high fructose corn syrup, artificial flavors, and synthetic dyes like Red 40 and Blue 1. While sugar-free versions exist, they swap sugar for artificial sweeteners like aspartame, which doesn’t elevate the quality.
Popsicle’s specialty lines—like Firecrackers or Scribblers—fare better, but the classics remain a mixed bag. They’re a sentimental favorite, not a top-tier contender.
9. Otter Pops
Next up is Otter Pops, those plastic-sleeved freezer pops that scream summer pool parties. Available in six zippy flavors like Blue Raspberry, Strawberry, and Lemonade, Otter Pops are a lightweight, fun option that earns a spot at number 9. They’re not gourmet, but they’ve improved their recipe over the years to appeal to a slightly more discerning crowd.
The flavor profile is unabashedly bold and artificial, leaning into a candy-like sweetness that kids (and kids at heart) adore. Blue Raspberry pops with a tart, electric vibe, while Strawberry delivers a sugary punch. They’re refreshing, but the taste doesn’t mimic real fruit—it’s more like a frozen Kool-Aid. On the ingredient front, Otter Pops have ditched high fructose corn syrup and artificial colors in favor of fruit juice and natural flavorings, which is a step up from their neon-hued past. Still, sugar and stabilizers like guar gum dominate, keeping them firmly in treat territory rather than health food. They’re affordable, widely available, and a nostalgic crowd-pleaser, but they lack the depth to climb higher on this list.
8. Annie’s Organic Fruit Pops
At number 8, Annie’s Organic Fruit Pops bring a wholesome twist to the popsicle game. Known for its bunny-shaped mac and cheese, Annie’s ventures into frozen treats with options like Cheerful Cherry and Grapes Galore, emphasizing organic ingredients and a lower sugar profile.
Flavor-wise, Annie’s nails a simple, fruit-driven taste. The Cherry flavor shines with a strong, authentic note that avoids the medicinal aftertaste of cheaper cherry pops, while the Grape offers a mellow, juicy sweetness. They’re not as intense as some competitors, which might disappoint thrill-seekers, but the balance feels just right for a lighter treat.
Ingredients are a highlight: organic fruit juice, cane sugar, and minimal additives like citric acid and natural flavors. With only 5 grams of added sugar per pop, they’re a guilt-free indulgence compared to the 20-plus grams in many traditional popsicles. The downside? Limited flavor variety and a slightly icy texture hold them back from greatness.
Still, Annie’s is a solid pick for organic enthusiasts.
7. Goodpop
Goodpop slides into number 7 with a mission to make “popsicles with a purpose.” Founded in Texas by a college student tired of artificial junk, Goodpop offers flavors like Watermelon Agave and Orange Cream, blending real fruit with cleaner ingredients.
The flavor experience is bright and refreshing. Watermelon Agave bursts with juicy, summery goodness, tempered by a subtle sweetness that doesn’t overwhelm. Orange Cream mimics a creamsicle with a dairy-free twist, using coconut for a smooth, tropical vibe. These pops taste natural without feeling watered down, though some flavors (like Hibiscus Mint) can be polarizing. Ingredients are a strong suit: fruit juice, cane sugar, agave, and guar gum keep things simple and pronounceable. No artificial colors or flavors here—just real stuff. They’re a bit pricier and melt quickly, but Goodpop’s commitment to quality and creativity earns it a respectable spot.
6. Outshine Fruit Bars
Outshine Fruit Bars take the number 6 position with a reputation as a freezer aisle staple. Available in classics like Strawberry, Lime, and Tangerine, plus creamy coconut options, Outshine balances bold flavor with decent ingredients.
The taste is a standout: Strawberry delivers a ripe, summery burst, while Lime offers a tart, zesty kick that’s pure refreshment. Tangerine edges out traditional orange with its vibrant, tangy depth. The texture is smooth rather than icy, making each bite satisfying. Ingredients include fruit puree, cane sugar, and juice concentrates, with stabilizers like guar gum and carob bean gum. Most flavors hover around 17 grams of added sugar, which is high but not unusual for the category. Outshine avoids artificial colors and flavors, and some varieties pack a vitamin C boost. They’re widely available and consistently tasty, though the sugar content keeps them from cracking the top five.
5. JonnyPops
JonnyPops lands at number 5 with a unique blend of simplicity and indulgence. Offering flavors like Strawberries & Cream and Cherry, JonnyPops combines fruit with a creamy twist that sets it apart from pure fruit bars.
Flavor-wise, these pops are a treat. Strawberries & Cream melds ripe berry goodness with a rich, creamy finish—think frozen smoothie on a stick. Cherry pops with a bright, authentic taste that’s sweet but not cloying. The texture is lush and less icy than most, thanks to the cream component. Ingredients include fruit, cane sugar, heavy cream (or oat milk in dairy-free versions), and a pinch of salt. With 9-11 grams of added sugar, they’re lower than many competitors, though the cream adds calories. JonnyPops keeps it natural with no artificial additives, and each stick even features a “kindness message”—a quirky touch. They’re a delightful middle ground between health and decadence.
4. Chloe’s Fruit Pops
Chloe’s Fruit Pops claim the number 4 spot with a minimalist approach that pays off. Founded by a former attorney seeking clean eats during pregnancy, Chloe’s offers flavors like Raspberry and Mango with just three ingredients: fruit, water, and cane sugar.
The flavor is pure and intense. Raspberry hits with a tart, juicy punch that tastes like frozen summer berries, while Mango delivers a tropical sweetness that’s smooth and satisfying. These pops avoid artificial aftertastes, letting the fruit shine. The texture is dense and creamy for a fruit-only pop, though they melt fast. Ingredients couldn’t be simpler—nothing artificial, no stabilizers beyond what’s naturally in the fruit. At 70-90 calories and 17-20 grams of added sugar, they’re not low-sugar, but the quality justifies it. Chloe’s partnerships with kid-friendly brands like Marvel add fun, but the premium price and smaller pack sizes keep it just shy of the podium.
3. Open Nature Fruit Bars
Open Nature Fruit Bars snag number 3 with a focus on natural simplicity. Available at stores like Safeway and Albertsons, flavors like Strawberry and Mango-Veggie Blend offer a high-quality option without the fuss.
Flavor is where Open Nature excels. Strawberry bursts with fresh, ripe taste—uncomplicated but delicious. The Mango-Veggie Blend sneaks in vegetables like carrot for a subtle twist that’s still fruity and fun. They’re smooth and satisfying, not icy. Ingredients are clean: fruit puree, cane sugar, water, and natural stabilizers like guar gum and xanthan gum. No artificial colors or flavors, and some flavors incorporate veggie juice for added nutrition. At 12 grams of added sugar, they’re reasonable for a treat. Open Nature’s wide availability and consistent quality make it a freezer must-have, though it lacks the gourmet flair of higher-ranked brands.
2. Talenti Mini Sorbetto Bars
Talenti, famous for its gelato, takes number 2 with its Mini Sorbetto Bars. Flavors like Roman Raspberry and Alphonso Mango bring a gourmet edge to the popsicle world, blending sophistication with accessibility.
The flavor is exceptional. Roman Raspberry offers a sweet-tart balance that’s fresh and vibrant, while Alphonso Mango delivers a silky, tropical richness that’s pure bliss. The texture is velvety—more sorbet than popsicle—setting it apart from icy competitors. Ingredients include fruit puree, cane sugar, and water, with natural stabilizers like carob gum. No artificial additives here, just premium quality. At 70-80 calories and 17-19 grams of added sugar, they’re indulgent but not excessive. The small size makes them easy to enjoy, though they melt quickly. Talenti’s near-perfect execution falls just short of the top spot due to its narrower flavor range.
1. 365 by Whole Foods Market Fruit Bars
Topping our list is 365 by Whole Foods Market Fruit Bars, the gold standard for store-bought popsicles. Available in flavors like Strawberry and Coconut, these bars combine unbeatable flavor with top-notch ingredients.
The taste is phenomenal. Strawberry tastes like frozen ripe berries—sweet, juicy, and authentic. Coconut adds a creamy, tropical note that’s pure summer in every bite. The texture is smooth and substantial, avoiding the pitfalls of iciness. Ingredients are pristine: real fruit, cane sugar, water, and natural stabilizers like guar gum. No artificial anything, just honest goodness. At 120 calories and 20 grams of added sugar for Strawberry (less for other flavors), they’re a treat, but the quality shines through. Widely available at Whole Foods, affordable, and consistently delicious, 365 takes the crown for its perfect balance of flavor and integrity.
Final Thoughts
From nostalgic classics to modern health-conscious options, the popsicle landscape offers something for everyone.
Whether you crave the bold artificial zing of Otter Pops or the pure fruit bliss of 365 Fruit Bars, flavor and ingredients shape the experience. Our top picks—365, Talenti, and Open Nature—stand out for their natural profiles and delicious execution, while brands like Popsicle and Otter Pops lean on nostalgia over substance. Next time you’re browsing the freezer aisle, reach for one of these 10 and savor the chill. What’s your favorite popsicle brand? Let us know—we’re always ready to taste-test a new contender!
