What is the secret to a good Philly cheesesteak?

Posted on

What is the secret to a good Philly cheesesteak?



Prep time

Cooking time

Total time


The Philly cheesesteak is an iconic sandwich that has garnered a passionate following far beyond its Philadelphia roots. Its appeal lies in its simplicity: thinly sliced ribeye steak, melted cheese, and a long, crusty hoagie roll, sometimes topped with fried onions, peppers, or mushrooms. But the secret to a truly great Philly cheesesteak is more nuanced, involving a delicate balance of quality ingredients, preparation, and tradition.

Quality Ingredients

The foundation of a good Philly cheesesteak starts with the quality of its components. The steak, usually ribeye, is prized for its marbling and flavor. It must be sliced thinly, which allows it to cook quickly and evenly, ensuring tenderness. The cheese choice also plays a critical role, with the most authentic versions using Cheez Whiz, provolone, or American cheese. Each cheese offers a different flavor profile and level of creaminess, with Cheez Whiz being the most traditional and favored for its unique taste and texture. The bread is equally important; a fresh, soft yet sturdy hoagie roll is crucial to hold the ingredients together without becoming soggy.

Preparation and Cooking Technique

How the steak is cooked and the sandwich assembled are key to achieving the quintessential Philly cheesesteak experience. The steak should be cooked on a flat top grill at a high temperature, allowing it to develop a slight char while remaining juicy. If onions or other vegetables are added, they should be sautéed to perfection, tender yet slightly crisp. When it comes to cheese, it should be thoroughly melted and well-distributed, ensuring each bite is creamy and flavorful. The assembly must be done quickly, with the cheese often added on top of the meat on the grill to melt, before being scooped onto the roll.

Tradition and Personal Preference

While the basics of a Philly cheesesteak are straightforward, variations and personal preferences play a significant role in what many consider the “secret” to the best sandwich. Some purists argue that the only true Philly cheesesteak comes from specific, storied establishments in Philadelphia itself, where decades of tradition shape their preparation methods. However, the choice between Cheez Whiz, provolone, or American cheese, the addition of onions or peppers, and the degree of doneness for the steak can all vary according to individual taste, making the quest for the perfect cheesesteak a personal journey.

The Role of Atmosphere

The atmosphere of where a Philly cheesesteak is enjoyed can also contribute to its overall appeal. Eating a cheesesteak in Philadelphia, amidst the city’s vibrant culture and history, can enhance the experience. The bustling cheesesteak shops, often with long lines and a no-nonsense ordering system, add to the charm and authenticity of the sandwich.

The secret to a good Philly cheesesteak lies in the quality of its ingredients, the precision of its preparation, and the traditions that have shaped its legacy. Whether it’s enjoyed in a renowned Philadelphia establishment or made at home, the Philly cheesesteak continues to be a beloved classic, with its simple yet irresistible combination of flavors and textures. The true secret, perhaps, is that the perfect Philly cheesesteak is the one that best satisfies individual taste, a testament to the sandwich’s enduring appeal and versatility.

The secret to a good Philly cheesesteak lies not just in its ingredients but in the harmony of its simple components coming together to create a quintessential American sandwich that has won hearts far beyond its Philadelphia roots. At its core, a Philly cheesesteak is a marvel of culinary simplicity: thinly sliced ribeye steak, melted cheese, and a long, crusty roll. Yet, the devil, as they say, is in the details. Here’s a deep dive into what makes a Philly cheesesteak not just good, but great.

Quality of Beef

The choice of beef is critical. Ribeye is the traditional choice for its perfect balance of flavor and fat, essential for both taste and tenderness. The beef should be sliced very thinly, a technique that not only ensures it cooks quickly but also integrates better with the cheese and onions, allowing each bite to meld together in perfect harmony.

The Bread

The roll is more than just a vessel; it’s a crucial component that needs to strike a balance between being sturdy enough to hold its contents without falling apart and soft enough to bite through easily. Amoroso rolls are a favorite in Philadelphia, but outside the city, any fresh, high-quality hoagie roll with a soft interior and slightly crusty exterior will do the trick.

Cheese Choices

While there’s some debate among purists, the three most commonly accepted cheese options are American cheese, provolone, and Cheez Whiz. American cheese offers a creamy melt, provolone adds a sharper taste, and Cheez Whiz provides a gooey, indulgent texture and bold, tangy flavor. The choice of cheese can significantly influence the overall flavor profile of the sandwich.

The Art of Cooking

The technique used to cook the steak plays a pivotal role. The steak should be cooked quickly on a flat top griddle at a high temperature. This method ensures the meat is tender and juicy, with a slightly caramelized exterior. Cooking the onions alongside the meat, allowing them to pick up the beef’s flavors and adding their sweetness to the mix, is another trick of the trade.

Assembly and Customization

A good Philly cheesesteak is about balance in its assembly. The cheese can be laid directly on the roll or melted atop the steak on the griddle, ensuring it permeates the meat. While traditionalists might argue that a true Philly cheesesteak needs little more than meat, cheese, and bread, others welcome additions like sautéed onions, mushrooms, or green peppers.

The “Authentic” Experience

Part of what makes a Philly cheesesteak so special is its unpretentious roots and the experience of eating one. Whether it’s from a street-side vendor in Philadelphia or a dedicated sandwich shop, the best Philly cheesesteak is often served in a no-frills, straightforward manner, focusing on the quality of its ingredients and the joy of its consumption.

The secret to a good Philly cheesesteak lies in its simplicity, the quality of its ingredients, and the attention to detail in its preparation. From the choice of beef to the type of cheese and bread, each element plays a critical role in creating a sandwich that’s greater than the sum of its parts. Whether you’re a purist or an innovator, the essence of a great Philly cheesesteak remains the same: a delicious, satisfying sandwich that’s emblematic of Philadelphia’s rich culinary culture.


Beginner-friendly recipes / Beverages / Coffee Recipes / Easy Recipes / foods / Quick recipes / recipe / Recipe collections / What is the secret to a good Philly cheesesteak

You might also like these recipes